The Great Constituent Trek


Roadshow to Prescient Securities Clients considering whether there are rebalancing effects present in trading the Top 40 index in SA.

PSec Roadshow
Cape Town, Johannesburg

In this note we test for the existence or otherwise of an index effect for stocks either entering or exiting the FTSE/JSE Top 40 benchmark index. The premise for our study follows from the notable increase in assets under management of passive funds globally, and in South Africa, in recent years. We explore whether periodic index rebalancing produces a distortive pricing effect that can be profitably exploited. For the Top 40, the rebalancing date is preceded by nearly two weeks of public knowledge of the constituents entering and exiting the index, following a week of the market’s ability to calculate the same. As passive funds are generally more (or arguably exclusively) sensitive to tracking error rather than prices, nearly all of this trade would have to be completed on the day before the official rebalancing becomes effective, as evidenced by a very large spike in trading. The present paper achieves the following.

We explain the current Top 40 rebalancing process, discussing the timing thereof, and considering the changes in volume and return around these event days.

  • We find that the day before the official rebalancing, trade for entrant and deletion stocks are significantly higher, largely following the simultaneous rebalancing of passive funds;

  • We find no increase (decrease) in the price of additions (deletions) on the rebalancing date, finding rather a general decline (increase) in prices, possibly pointing to some overshooting;

  • We find a profitable long-short trading signal generated by the Index Effect, but only when executing this at the date of calculation (before constituent changes are publicly announced) and exiting before official rebalancing;

  • Lastly, we do not see a persistent medium term Index Effect on stocks, finding rather that after rebalancing, both additions and deletions underperform the market in the following months. Volatility also remains similar after rebalancing for both. The only noticeable effect on rebalancing stocks is a permanent increase (decrease) in volume traded.

  • Our recommendation is that clients who closely track the Top 40 can achieve portfolio efficiency gains by selling deletions in advance of official rebalancing, while fund managers able to profit off a long-short rebalancing effect strategy should enter and exit the positions early, as detailed in the paper.

Nico Katzke
Head of Portfolio Solutions

Head of Portfolio Solutions